FAQ's and myth-busting Background information about One Somerset

The future of local government in Somerset

For more than two years the Leaders and Chief Executives of all Somerset’s five local authorities have been discussing the future shape of local government in the county.

The Leader of Somerset County Council, Councillor David Fothergill, has underlined his view that One Somerset – a single, Unitary Authority – is the best way forward.

Frequently asked questions

Why do we need to change?
All the Councils agree on one thing – the current way of working must change. It is wasteful, costs too much and all the headquarters buildings are remote and difficult for people to get to.

A single Authority will remove the waste, cut costs and join up with smaller parish, town and city councils so it is easier for people to take part in the big decisions that matter in their local communities – things like setting parking charges, where to build new houses, sites for mobile phone masts and improving their local roads.

Why now?
We can’t go on with the current level of waste and inefficiency. Running five different councils with five separate management teams, five sets of back office teams, five sets of contracts, five call centres – it is duplication and wasteful.

A single Authority will keep all the current services running, but it will remove this duplication – why have five management teams when you could have one? Why have five call centres when you can have one? Why have five back office teams when you could have one? It just makes sense to change.

Where else can I see a single unitary council in action?
Single councils are everywhere. Just look around the borders of Somerset and you will see Dorset, Wiltshire, Bath and North East Somerset, North Somerset, Bristol, Torbay, Plymouth and Cornwall. And there are loads of others around the country.

A single Authority for Somerset will mean we will have a powerful voice when lobbying government for more funding for our residents. All the unitaries around us get extra money for major projects like roads – Somerset must not be left behind.

How does changing to Unitary work?
The decision is made by Government, not by the local councils. The Government sets out its own tests including the size of the unitary authority and asks if important partners support the idea. All five councils would then be scrapped, and a new Authority created with new councillors elected.

A single Authority for Somerset ticks off the boxes for the Government’s own tests. It is the right size, has the buy-in from key partners like the Police and Crime Commissioner.

Why can’t the Districts and County agree?
All the Councils agree on one thing – the current way of working must change. But they can’t agree on the next step. A single Authority for Somerset is widely accepted as the right step but sometimes the right decision needs community leaders to make brave and difficult choices.

Can I make a comment or ask a question?
If you have a question, or you just want to get in touch you can email us at onesomerset@somerset.gov.uk or you can use the contact form to ask a question.

How much money will it save?
The initial independent report suggested that savings in the region of over £40m a year are achievable. We believe that this is too high, and we don’t want to exaggerate so have carried out our own assessment using two independent sets of experts.

We believe that a single Authority for Somerset will save £18.5m in the first year – and each and every year after that – a massive saving that we can spend on better services for you. This is money which can be reinvested into vital frontline services in your neighbourhood. We also know there will be costs in setting up the Authority – we estimate this will be a one-off cost of £16.5m. We want to hear from you about where you think this unitary dividend should be spent – perhaps climate change, better transport, more social housing? You can contact us here: onesomerset@somerset.gov.uk

How will having one single council help improve local decision making?
At the moment, key decisions which affect you are made in remote district and county council offices. The One Somerset model will end this by establishing 15 to 20 new Local Community Networks (LCNs) across Somerset to give local people the chance to shape their own communities. These will have real constitutional powers to scrutinise, shape policy, and take decisions. There will also be an enhanced role for town, parish and district councils with services and assets devolved should they wish.

How many jobs will be lost through the process of forming a new single council?
The business case has identified a need for around 340 fewer posts; these may include roles such as executives, senior managers and some duplicated back-office functions. There will also be 169 fewer councillors across Somerset in the new organisation.

This is well within the current annual staff turnover level of the Somerset councils, so any redundancies required would be managed through a targeted, voluntary approach. Compulsory redundancies would be kept to a minimum and redeployment and retraining for alternative roles would be prioritised. Working closely with trade union colleagues and other staff groups will enable this.

Why are you doing this when you should be focused on Covid-19?
Covid-19 remains our number one priority. Every day, 24-7. SCC has been rightly praised for the leading role it has taken alongside the NHS to combat Covid-19. But all councils across Somerset have been able to progress with other work too and for SCC that includes looking ahead too.

What happens when the One Somerset Business Case is submitted to the Government?
The Secretary of State for Housing and Local Government will consider and consult on the proposal – and any others that may be submitted regarding local government reform in Somerset. The consultation is expected to take place in late winter/early spring, with the Secretary of State expected to make a decision on the preferred proposal between June and July 2021. The timescales are set by Government. We will update this page with further information as soon as it becomes available.

Myth-busting

“New unitary councils never deliver the savings promised”
Unitary councils have a great record on delivering promised savings (see the EY report for the CCN, 2016). Our detailed business case sets out exactly where these savings will be delivered. In some instances, savings have exceeded forecasts (Cornwall and Wiltshire are local examples) – we are confident that will be the case here in Somerset too.

“Somerset County Council is only doing this to get more money for its own services”
Somerset County Council has just published its annual report with incredibly healthy finances. Savings reserves are high, and costs have been managed to within budget. In addition, some income dependant District Councils are really feeling the financial pinch following the unprecedented Covid-19 pandemic and the County Council has already offered to assist with their ongoing cash flow challenges.

“This proposal will lead to more services being run out of Taunton”
At the moment, county and district council services are run from remote headquarters buildings in Taunton, Bridgwater, Shepton Mallet and out-of-town Yeovil. A single council for Somerset proposes ultra-local community involvement in decisions, with parish, town and city councils having more of a say and will free up funding for local people and local needs. It’s interesting to note that more Somerset County Council staff work in each district than the district councils themselves employ – not many people know that!

“A single council will be too big”
A single council in Somerset would be similar in size to the many other county unitaries across the country and our neighbours Dorset and Wiltshire. The proposal for One Somerset is also the only option which meets the government criteria which states that any new unitary authority must be larger than 300-400,000 people. With a population of 560,000 it would not be possible to split Somerset into two unitaries – both would be well under the minimum population specified by the Secretary of State and the western unitary (assuming an east-west split) would have levels of deprivation over twice that in the east. We will ensure decision making remains local using the LCN model set out above.

“The savings are aspirational and won’t be delivered”
The savings of £18.5m each and every year are consistent with the business case levels made by other county unitaries (Cornwall, Wiltshire, Dorset, Buckinghamshire). These include only the initial savings and not the significant savings of many millions of pounds we believe is possible over the coming years.

“There will be a democratic deficit with less councillors”
The One Somerset model will remove an unnecessary layer of government and reduce the number of councillors, some of whom are both county and district councillors. There will still be similar levels of electors per elected member as in other unitary counties (4,302 electors per member).

Ask a question

If you have a question, or you just want to get in touch you can email us at onesomerset@somerset.gov.uk 

Or you can use the form below: